'May your choices reflect your hopes, not your fears' Nelson Mandela...
 

 

 

 
indy 2
 

The case for Scottish independence looks stronger post-Brexit

The decision to leave the EU changes terms of debate north of the border, writes Nicholas Macpherson

The EU referendum last month has raised existential issues of nationality across the British Isles. Applications for Irish passports are at a record level, with even Ian Paisley Jr, the Democratic Unionist MP, tweeting: “My advice is if you are entitled to [a] second passport then take one.” Meanwhile, the pressure for another referendum on Scottish independence is mounting.
With the UK leaving the EU, there is a golden opportunity for proponents of Scottish independence to reappraise their economic prospectus. Clearly, membership of the EU will lie at the heart of it. That will enable Scotland to have access to the biggest market in the world without the uncertainties that are likely to face the rest of the UK for many years to come. It would also provide a historic opportunity for Edinburgh to develop further as a financial centre, as London-based institutions hedge their bets on the location of staff and activities. If Royal Bank of Scotland, the state-backed bank, relocates its headquarters as part of that process, that would strengthen the long-term sustainability of the Scottish financial sector. How quickly an independent Scotland could join the EU is of course highly uncertain. Spain is unlikely to agree to automatic membership because of concerns about secessionist pressures in Catalonia. All the same, the EU has a huge interest in fast-tracking membership for a country whose citizens have been members of the bloc for 43 years and have voted to remain by 62 per cent to 38 per cent. Then there is the question of currency. In the run-up to the 2014 independence referendum, the Scottish National party government missed a trick by advocating a unilateral monetary union between an independent Scotland and the rest of the UK. The Treasury had had enough problems with fixed currency regimes in the 20th century without wanting to enter into one in the 21st. The history of monetary unions teaches us that they require more political integration rather than less — as the eurozone has discovered to its cost. In any case, an independent Scotland would have no interest in seeking to tie its currency to a country that wishes to put more distance between itself and the EU. It is surely time, therefore, for the Scottish government to commit to creating a Scottish pound supported by its own central bank. That would not preclude the monetary authorities of an independent Scotland from shadowing sterling, just as the Danish central bank shadows the euro. In the longer term, there could be a case for tying the Scottish pound to the euro. And a long-term commitment to joining the single currency would almost certainly be a requirement of EU membership. But that does not mean Scotland would have to adopt the euro — at least not straight away. Sweden is theoretically obliged to join the single currency. But more than 20 years on from joining the EU, the prospects of its giving up the krona seem vanishingly remote. One of the Treasury’s worries in 2014 about the putative monetary union between an independent Scotland and the rest of the UK was the impact of the oil price cycle. With its own currency, Scotland would be much better placed to respond to an oil shock on the scale of the one that has taken place in the past two years. Interest rates and the Scottish pound could take the strain smoothing any adjustment in the real economy. The fall in the oil price from $100 a barrel to under $40 earlier this year is a reminder of the importance of sound public finances. There is no reason why small countries cannot be very successful economically. But generally those that are — Norway and Singapore come to mind — put great effort into establishing fiscal credibility. That generally means running fiscal surpluses in the good times, the better to insure against shocks in the bad times. The Treasury was concerned in 2014 that the Scottish government’s prospectus relied on over-optimistic oil price projections. But First Minister Nicola Sturgeon’s administration has since worked to bolster its fiscal credibility. John Swinney, Scottish finance secretary until earlier this year, was cautious about using the borrowing powers available under the existing fiscal arrangements. More importantly, he has taken steps to set up Scotland’s own independent fiscal council. There is now a much better opportunity for informed debate about public finances, taking into account changing North Sea oil production levels and wider demographic trends. The Scottish government can strengthen its credibility by setting out long-term plans for public services, public investment and social security, in particular pensions. It also has a chance to set out a tax policy for the longer term. An independent Scotland committed to the EU would have an extraordinary opportunity to attract inward investment as well as highly skilled migrants. But, since it will be competing with Ireland, it needs a tax system that is equally competitive. That points to low corporate taxes and keeping marginal rates of income tax down. It may also point to a smaller, more efficient state. The aftermath of the EU referendum contains many lessons. Perhaps the most important is that without a plan for what happens next you risk months, if not years, of uncertainty and drift. The Scottish government is in a unique position to take a more far-sighted approach. If it can develop a clear and coherent economic strategy ahead of any future referendum, it not only stands a better chance of winning it will also increase the probability that an independent Scotland inside the EU can hit the ground running. The writer was permanent secretary to the Treasury and is now visiting professor at King’s College London FT.com FT  

RSS Guido Fawkes.

  • Saturday Seven Up August 27, 2016
    This recess week 128,013 visitors visited 352,222 times viewing 547,667 pages. The top stories in order of popularity were: How British Empire Beats EU for Olympic Medals Corbyn’s Train Squat Doesn’t Stand Up Times Runs Full Page Ad for “China Heroes” Sturgeon Blames Brexit for Bust Stronger No Longer #Traingate Spin Before & After No, […]
    guidobard
  • Bob Crow Brigade Gun Wielding ISIS Fighters Slam Oily Smith August 26, 2016
    Hard left anti-ISIS fighters branding themselves the Bob Crow Brigade have slammed Owen “Oily” Smith’s desire to talk to ISIS. Armed with Kalashnikov assault rifles and standing in front of a wall in what appears to be a ruined town, fighters stand below graffiti which reads: “@OwenSmith2016 Want to talk to ISIS? Tell that to […]
    guidobard
  • Burkini Unbanned! August 26, 2016
    Guido was concerned that burkini wearing fair-skinned Irish girls would no longer be able to protect themselves from harmful UV rays on the beaches in the South of France as a result of the ban. Good news for freedom lovers, as France’s top administrative court strikes down the Villeneuve-Loubet burkini ban. Women on the Riviera who have […]
    guidobard
  • Act That Tried to Ban “Poppers” Bites August 26, 2016
    Crispin Blunt will be breathing a sigh of relief today, as figures released by the Home Office reveal the Psychoactive Substances Act stopped 332 “headshops” selling the contraband and shutdown 24 altogether, with 186 arrests. The act gained notoriety earlier this year when it was revealed that the government was to attempt a blanket ban on then “legal […]
    guidobard
  • Friday Caption Contest: Comfy Seat Edition August 26, 2016
    Entries in the comments please… The post Friday Caption Contest: Comfy Seat Edition appeared first on Guido Fawkes.
    guidobard
  • Serjeant at Arms Gets Complaint About Carolyn Harris August 26, 2016
    The Serjeant at Arms has been sent a complaint by one of Carolyn Harris’s constituents, demanding to know why she has granted a pass to lobbyist Lawrence Bailey who told Guido he was “not an employee or member of Carolyn’s staff.” The Serjeant’s office can now begin the official complaints procedure, which could see Bailey have his […]
    guidobard
  • Sainsbury Broke Labour Rules, Purging Likely August 26, 2016
    Top Labour donor Baron Sainsbury’s grant of over £2 million to the Lib Dems this year means, without any doubt, he has broken Labour’s strict membership rules. The 2016 rulebook, Chapter 2 clause I section 4 paragraph B calls for the automatic exclusion of any members who “supports a political organisation other than an official Labour […]
    guidobard
  • Hillary Clinton Attacks Farage and Alt-Right Movement August 26, 2016
    “Just yesterday, one of Britain’s most prominent right wing leaders – a man called Nigel Farage – who stoked anti-immigrant sentiments to win the referendum to have Britain leave the European Union, campaigned with Donald Trump in Mississippi. Farage has called for a ban on the children of legal immigrants from public schools and health […]
    order-order
  • Who Said it: Blair or Smith? August 25, 2016
    Can you tell the “oily” leadership candidate from his hated predecessor? The post Who Said it: Blair or Smith? appeared first on Guido Fawkes.
    guidobard
  • EU Leaders Discussing Brexit Without Britain, Again August 25, 2016
    Leaders of every EU member state bar Britain will meet in Bratislava in mid-September to “continue a political reflection” post-Brexit. The event, which was scheduled after the last meeting in Brussels, is ostensibly for the leaders to debate “further reforms in line with our strategic agenda”. This will almost certainly include extensive discussions around Brexit. Frustratingly both Merkel […]
    guidobard
  • Labour MPs Love Theresa May As Well August 25, 2016
    It’s not just Labour’s former advisers who like Theresa May – their MPs think she’s impressive too. Theresa May was deemed “most impressive parliamentarian” by no less than 35% of Labour MPs, putting her second on the leadership table only to be beaten by Cameron in an Ipsos MORI poll of members. While May was deemed impressive by […]
    guidobard
  • Labour Adviser Created “Theresa May for PM” Campaign August 25, 2016
    A former Labour adviser who denied supporting Theresa May was behind the pro-Theresa May campaign Twibbon. Jonny Chambers, who previously worked for Stella Creasy, lashed out on Twitter this morning after being barred from the Labour party after he “demonstrated support for the Conservative party on social media.” In a Facebook post, Chambers claimed that the […]
    guidobard
  • #TrainGate: Labour Voters Trust Corbyn August 25, 2016
    Labour voters showed their trust in Corbyn in a recent YouGov poll on TrainGate. 39% of current Labour voters believe Corbyn’s version of events – that there were no unreserved seats available – compared to 34% believing Virgin’s story. 44% think Corbyn was being dishonest but only 36% of Labour voters think that his dishonesty […]
    guidobard
  • MoD Spends More on Accountants Than Fighter Jets August 25, 2016
    The MoD spent £4.2 billion on “Technical, Financial Services and Other Services”. A handy statistical bulletin released today itemised the £20 billion of the defence budget spent within the UK in 2014/15: “The industry group that received the highest level of expenditure from the MOD was ‘Technical, Financial Services and Other Business Services’, at just over £4.2 […]
    guidobard
  • Farage to Trump “I Come to You With a Message of Hope and Optimism” August 25, 2016
    Will the lessons of the Brexit campaign transfer across the Atlantic? At a campaign rally speech in Mississippi Farage chimed with Trump’s anti-corporatist messages, his championing of “ordinary people let down by a politically correct political class”. 202 years to the day since the British burnt down the White House Farage said Trump could beat […]
    order-order
  • Stronger No Longer August 24, 2016
    The Stronger In campaign has finally thrown in the towel, all those corporate millions, Roland Rudd’s spin, Cameron and Osborne’s careers and all they have to show for it is a Commander of the British Empire for Will Straw. Will says the “Stronger In” organisation is no longer. Which is amateurism until the end. The […]
    order-order
  • Mosley’s Money Funding Watson’s Expanded Team August 24, 2016
    Tom Watson is spending most of his £200,000 from fellow free-press hater Max Mosley on four new staff members. The fan of German-themed parties with prostitutes is generously bolstering Watson’s operation… Labour’s deputy leader is recruiting a new political advisor, writer, head of policy, and correspondence assistant, with salaries ranging from £24,522 for the latter role […]
    guidobard
  • #Traingate Spin Before & After August 24, 2016
    Corbyn spokesman last night: “That line about only wanting to sit with his wife is nonsense and not from us.” Corbyn today: “Yes I did look for two empty seats together so I could sit down with my wife to talk to her.” Hat-tip: Harry Cole The post #Traingate Spin Before & After appeared first […]
    order-order
  • Danczuk’s Fundraising Flop August 24, 2016
    Simon Danczuk has raised just £20 out of his £500 goal for a local charity since beginning his funding drive in May. The Rochdale MP’s summer could hardly get worse, since first tweeting that he would be fundraising for the Growth Project in May he has attracted just one donor. Danczuk has just 31 days […]
    guidobard
  • Corbyn on TrainGate August 24, 2016
    Labour leader @JeremyCorbyn reluctantly answers a question from @DMcCaffreySKY on #TrainGate https://t.co/nLPGEP48Xs — Sky News (@SkyNews) August 24, 2016 Darren McCaffrey provoked Corbyn’s famous ire with the MSM when asking him questions about TrainGate. Corbyn’s story changed, claiming he couldn’t find two (rather than one) seats. Still more believable than Smith’s excuses this morning… The post Corbyn […]
    guidobard

RSS Bella Caledonia.

  • Remember the Panama Papers? August 26, 2016
    How quickly we forget. It was just four months ago we learned of the role of Panama in helping so many rich and famous folk to dodge their fair share of the tax burden. It was even more disgusting to see so many politicians in the rogues gallery. The first response from the Panamanian law […]
    Bella Caledonia Editor
  • The Age o Excellence August 26, 2016
    Pairt Twa o John Hodgart’s series on Scottish Culture in the curriculum. Efter mony curricular revisions in the saicond hauf o the twentieth century, the brave new world o Curriculum for Excellence was revealed unto us in the third millennium, wi a haill new vision o teachin an learnin an new articles o faith. But nae […]
    Bella Caledonia Editor
  • What does GERS tell us? August 26, 2016
    The publication of GERS – an assessment of Scotland’s nominal public finances – is by common consent the most tedious event in our political calendar. Unionists and nationalists alike spin the figures for cheap political points. Currently, the unionists are winning: GERS 2015-16, released today, show Scotland with a net fiscal deficit (the annual gap […]
    Bella Caledonia Editor
  • The Art of Labour August 26, 2016
    Today Jeremy Corbyn is launching a ‘comprehensive strategy for the arts’ in Edinburgh, but it will have little or nothing to do with Edinburgh or Scotland, where art, culture and education are all devolved matters. It is another sign of how semi-detached and culturally removed Labour is that this could be happening at all. Although […]
    Bella Caledonia Editor
  • Lobbyist Scotland, Brexit and the Closed-Door System August 25, 2016
    I am a committed democrat, a yes voter and a Remainer. I am also, god help me, a Labour Party member. In the run up to the European referendum, I became familiar with Tom Harris, former Labour MP for Glasgow South East who had a Damascene and well-publicised conversion to Brexit. In some fairly robust […]
    Bella Caledonia Editor
  • Rappers v Poets August 25, 2016
    This from Drew Devine @WerdSOS just about says it all on Scotland & Brexit. [Get more from him at Bandcamp here] Likes(9)Dislikes(3)
    Bella Caledonia Editor
  • How I Want Thee August 25, 2016
    ‘How I want thee, humorous Hogarth! Thou, I hear, a pleasant rogue art. Were but you and I acquainted, Every monster should be painted: You should try your graving tools On this odious group of fools.’ The above almost romantic plea from Jonathan Swift to William Hogarth comes in the penultimate stanza in Swift’s poem […]
    Bella Caledonia Editor
  • GERS: or, A Wayward Exercise in the Capricious August 24, 2016
    The most important matter regarding GERS is not the output, the ‘figures’, the so-called facts; the most important matter is the methodology used to create them. Without a sound, dependable, stable methodology we have nothing: nothing. The methodology is provided in ‘Government Expenditure and Revenue Scotland: Detailed Revenue Methodology Paper 2014-15’ (http://www.gov.scot/Resource/0049/00495355.pdf). The Methodology Paper […]
    Bella Caledonia Editor
  • Clare Balding’s Favourite Rower August 23, 2016
    I’m on my annual staycation and I inadvertently stumble on a copy of The Scotsman over breakfast. With a listless dread I turn the pages when, on page four, this scoop jumps out at me: “Clare Balding’s Favourite Rower Revealed”.*  I immediately alert the rest of the house and soon people are crowding around me, […]
    Bella Caledonia Editor
  • A Love letter to Scotland from an EU immigrant August 22, 2016
    All I remember is falling in love; fast, deep, lasting love. So I packed my bags, bid farewell to friends in Copenhagen and moved. This was in the early 1990s. My journey was as easy as it sounds because of the EU: no complicated border procedures, and my tuition fees were paid in full by […]
    Bella Caledonia Editor

RSS Wings Over Scotland.

  • GERS: The Movie August 27, 2016
    Chris Cairns
  • How to lose forever August 26, 2016
    This is the demented, McCarthyite state of madness the Labour Party has reached: This is a party now openly rejecting anyone as a member who has ever supported any other party. We’d take a minute to try to explain to them how the arithmetic of that one works out, but they’re a long, long way beyond […]
    Rev. Stuart Campbell
  • Living in a world of quicksand August 26, 2016
    Scottish Labour won a council by-election in Fife last night, held after the long-serving Communist Party/independent councillor Willie Clarke (seen on the last page of our Charlie Hebdo feature here) stepped down due to ill health. The successful candidate Mary Lockhart was understandably jubilant, but there were a couple of what seemed like pertinent facts missing […]
    Rev. Stuart Campbell
  • Not a dry seat in the house August 25, 2016
    This can’t be a good sign.
    Rev. Stuart Campbell
  • At home with the Kardashians August 25, 2016
    The new January-June 2016 sales figures for “regional” Scottish newspapers: Aberdeen Evening Express: 27,441 copies per day (-11.3% vs Jan-Jun 2015) Dundee Courier: 41,243 (-8.5%) Dundee Evening Telegraph: 16,354 (-9.5%) Edinburgh Evening News: 20,235 (-14.1%) Glasgow Evening Times: 25,679 (-14.3%) The Herald: 30,402 (-11.6%) Paisley Daily Express: 4,986 (-7.4%) The Press & Journal: 54,270 (-7.2%) Scotland On Sunday: 19,059 […]
    Rev. Stuart Campbell
  • The kingdom of wishful thinking August 24, 2016
    One thing you can always guarantee on GERS Day is that the latest set of figures for Scotland’s devolved economy inside the UK will trigger another uncontrolled spurt of “SNP HONEYMOON OVER” articles from the nation’s dogged commentariat. Today we’ve seen already examples (links below) from two ex-Scotsman editors, Iain Martin and Magnus Linklater, the […]
    Rev. Stuart Campbell
  • The SIX key facts about GERS August 24, 2016
    We originally wrote this article in March, in response to the Government Expenditure and Revenue Scotland (better known as GERS) figures for 2014-15. We’ve updated it to take account of events since that time, of which there’s been one rather major one. Today saw the publication (just five months after the 2014-15 GERS) of the 2015-16 […]
    Rev. Stuart Campbell
  • And so it begins August 24, 2016
    “Black hole” grows by £2.4bn in the space of four minutes: Hopefully we’ll soon have the sort of totally definitive clarity we got last time.
    Rev. Stuart Campbell
  • Feeling yourself disintegrate August 23, 2016
    “CRISIS-HIT POLICE TO AXE 300 OFFICERS”, blares the front-page lead of today’s Scottish Daily Mail. (Along with some exciting Prince Harry not-news.) “SECRET cuts to police numbers will see hundreds of officers axed as the single force faces a deepening cash crisis. The Mail can reveal controversial proposals to reduce frontline manpower – while violent and sex […]
    Rev. Stuart Campbell
  • One for the archives August 23, 2016
    Kezia Dugdale in yesterday’s Daily Record on the subject of Jeremy Corbyn: “We can’t pin our hopes on a leadership who speak only to the converted, rather than speaking to the country as a whole. I don’t think Jeremy can unite our party and lead us into government. He cannot appeal to a broad enough section […]
    Rev. Stuart Campbell

WP SlimStat