'May your choices reflect your hopes, not your fears' Nelson Mandela...
 

 

 

 
indy 2
 

The case for Scottish independence looks stronger post-Brexit

The decision to leave the EU changes terms of debate north of the border, writes Nicholas Macpherson

The EU referendum last month has raised existential issues of nationality across the British Isles. Applications for Irish passports are at a record level, with even Ian Paisley Jr, the Democratic Unionist MP, tweeting: “My advice is if you are entitled to [a] second passport then take one.” Meanwhile, the pressure for another referendum on Scottish independence is mounting.
With the UK leaving the EU, there is a golden opportunity for proponents of Scottish independence to reappraise their economic prospectus. Clearly, membership of the EU will lie at the heart of it. That will enable Scotland to have access to the biggest market in the world without the uncertainties that are likely to face the rest of the UK for many years to come. It would also provide a historic opportunity for Edinburgh to develop further as a financial centre, as London-based institutions hedge their bets on the location of staff and activities. If Royal Bank of Scotland, the state-backed bank, relocates its headquarters as part of that process, that would strengthen the long-term sustainability of the Scottish financial sector. How quickly an independent Scotland could join the EU is of course highly uncertain. Spain is unlikely to agree to automatic membership because of concerns about secessionist pressures in Catalonia. All the same, the EU has a huge interest in fast-tracking membership for a country whose citizens have been members of the bloc for 43 years and have voted to remain by 62 per cent to 38 per cent. Then there is the question of currency. In the run-up to the 2014 independence referendum, the Scottish National party government missed a trick by advocating a unilateral monetary union between an independent Scotland and the rest of the UK. The Treasury had had enough problems with fixed currency regimes in the 20th century without wanting to enter into one in the 21st. The history of monetary unions teaches us that they require more political integration rather than less — as the eurozone has discovered to its cost. In any case, an independent Scotland would have no interest in seeking to tie its currency to a country that wishes to put more distance between itself and the EU. It is surely time, therefore, for the Scottish government to commit to creating a Scottish pound supported by its own central bank. That would not preclude the monetary authorities of an independent Scotland from shadowing sterling, just as the Danish central bank shadows the euro. In the longer term, there could be a case for tying the Scottish pound to the euro. And a long-term commitment to joining the single currency would almost certainly be a requirement of EU membership. But that does not mean Scotland would have to adopt the euro — at least not straight away. Sweden is theoretically obliged to join the single currency. But more than 20 years on from joining the EU, the prospects of its giving up the krona seem vanishingly remote. One of the Treasury’s worries in 2014 about the putative monetary union between an independent Scotland and the rest of the UK was the impact of the oil price cycle. With its own currency, Scotland would be much better placed to respond to an oil shock on the scale of the one that has taken place in the past two years. Interest rates and the Scottish pound could take the strain smoothing any adjustment in the real economy. The fall in the oil price from $100 a barrel to under $40 earlier this year is a reminder of the importance of sound public finances. There is no reason why small countries cannot be very successful economically. But generally those that are — Norway and Singapore come to mind — put great effort into establishing fiscal credibility. That generally means running fiscal surpluses in the good times, the better to insure against shocks in the bad times. The Treasury was concerned in 2014 that the Scottish government’s prospectus relied on over-optimistic oil price projections. But First Minister Nicola Sturgeon’s administration has since worked to bolster its fiscal credibility. John Swinney, Scottish finance secretary until earlier this year, was cautious about using the borrowing powers available under the existing fiscal arrangements. More importantly, he has taken steps to set up Scotland’s own independent fiscal council. There is now a much better opportunity for informed debate about public finances, taking into account changing North Sea oil production levels and wider demographic trends. The Scottish government can strengthen its credibility by setting out long-term plans for public services, public investment and social security, in particular pensions. It also has a chance to set out a tax policy for the longer term. An independent Scotland committed to the EU would have an extraordinary opportunity to attract inward investment as well as highly skilled migrants. But, since it will be competing with Ireland, it needs a tax system that is equally competitive. That points to low corporate taxes and keeping marginal rates of income tax down. It may also point to a smaller, more efficient state. The aftermath of the EU referendum contains many lessons. Perhaps the most important is that without a plan for what happens next you risk months, if not years, of uncertainty and drift. The Scottish government is in a unique position to take a more far-sighted approach. If it can develop a clear and coherent economic strategy ahead of any future referendum, it not only stands a better chance of winning it will also increase the probability that an independent Scotland inside the EU can hit the ground running. The writer was permanent secretary to the Treasury and is now visiting professor at King’s College London FT.com FT  

RSS Guido Fawkes.

  • May Not Be True October 1, 2016
    Fantastic anecdote in Rachel Sylvester and Alice Thomson’s The Times puff piece for Theresa May this morning. Only snag, it didn’t happen, the PM has not been to the White House yet… The post May Not Be True appeared first on Guido Fawkes.
    order-order
  • Saturday Seven Up October 1, 2016
    This week 199,165 visitors visited 600,114 times viewing 976,129 pages. The top stories in order of popularity were: Momentum Mock Injured Soldiers Sunday at Labour Conference Shami Gets Brillo’d McDonnell Defends Calling McVey “Stain on Humanity” Germany Realises They’re Going to Be EU’s ATM Milne Edited Lewis Speech Without Telling Him Labour Illiterate on Illiteracy You’re […]
    WikiGuido
  • Jackie Walker Suspended By Labour September 30, 2016
    Press Association reports Jackie Walker has been suspended from the Labour Party. Again. Bye… The post Jackie Walker Suspended By Labour appeared first on Guido Fawkes.
    WikiGuido
  • End of the Party for the Telegraph September 30, 2016
    For the first time in recent memory there will be no Telegraph party at Tory conference. Traditionally the Torygraph bash has one of the more exclusive guestlists – Dave and George used to show up, Philip Hammond was once turned away – this year they’ve canned the whole thing. Sticking five figures behind the bar so execs […]
    WikiGuido
  • Guardian Launch Investigation Into Trot’s Traingate Coverage September 30, 2016
    MediaGuido understands the Guardian has launched an internal investigation after it emerged its original “traingate” news report was written by a Trot under a pseudonym. Private Eye found that “Charles B. Anthony”, who had the byline for the fictitious story about Corbyn sitting on the floor, was in fact a former Socialist Workers Party member called Anthony Casey. Somehow they published […]
    WikiGuido
  • Friday Caption Competition (Grab the Moobs Edition) September 30, 2016
    Come up with a witty caption in the comments and win a book. Handy reading if this lot get anywhere near power, the IEA’s edition of Friedrich Hayek’s “Road to Serfdom: With the Intellectuals and Socialism“. The post Friday Caption Competition (Grab the Moobs Edition) appeared first on Guido Fawkes.
    order-order
  • Mark Clarke’s Ex-Lover Launching New Tory Youth Group at Conference September 30, 2016
    Conservative Future, the youth wing of the Tory party, disappeared in disgrace following the Elliot Johnson suicide, with CCHQ cancelling its events at last year’s conference. 12 months on it is quietly returning in all but name. A series of events are planned in Birmingham using the name Conservative Youth, starting with a late night ‘Youth Reception’ hosted […]
    WikiGuido
  • Richard Murphy Wanted to ‘Do a Shami’ September 30, 2016
    This time last year tax blogger Richard Murphy was anointed the guru of Corbynomics, unofficially advising Jez and John on policy. His role was significant enough for David Cameron to make a sex joke about his “Joy of Tax” during his conference speech. Yet somewhere along the way the relationship soured. Murphy started to make a series […]
    WikiGuido
  • UKIP Gives Taxpayers 52% Rebate September 30, 2016
    After winning 3.9 million votes and just one seat, UKIP was entitled to £619,128 of Short Money last year. Their sole MP Douglas Carswell refused to take the full amount, sparking a bitter row with Nigel Farage, and irritating those in party HQ who had to find the money to pay staff wages. Something that did not always […]
    order-order
  • Lansman “Appalled” By Jackie Walker’s Conduct September 29, 2016
    Jackie Walker’s position as vice-chair of Momentum looks increasingly untenable after sources said Jon Lansman, previously a supporter and friend, had reached the end of his tether. A senior Jewish Labour source told Guido last night: “Very senior members of Momentum from Lansman downwards are appalled by this. They say they find Jackie a liability. They […]
    WikiGuido
  • Who is on Question Time Tonight September 29, 2016
    The post Who is on Question Time Tonight appeared first on Guido Fawkes.
    WikiGuido
  • Jackie Walker’s Friends in High Places September 29, 2016
    This photo appears to show Jeremy Corbyn dining with Jackie Walker’s partner Graham Bash in Liverpool this week. Jackie uploaded the picture to her own Facebook page on Saturday. Corbyn and Bash have been close friends for over 30 years, Bash edited the hard-left Labour Briefing publication of which Corbyn sat on the editorial board, and is treasurer […]
    WikiGuido
  • Grammar Critic in Labour PPB Went to £18,000-a-Year School September 29, 2016
    Labour’s new party political broadcast features a segment on how grammar schools are “elitist“. The Corbynista voicing his opposition to selective education is Abhijay Sood, an Imperial College student who is mates with the Momentum crowd. Naturally Abhijay attended the prestigious £18,000-a-year academically selective John Lyon school. So he’ll fit in well with his fellow selective education opponents at Momentum, […]
    WikiGuido
  • Voters Ask to Be Removed from McDonnell’s Constituency September 29, 2016
    With a multi-billion pound decision imminent currently Guido is receiving almost hourly presss releases related to the third runway. This one made Guido laugh.  Pro-Heathrow residents have written to the Boundary Commission demanding that they be removed from the anti-Heathrow expansion campaigning MP John McDonnell’s parliamentary constituency. Good luck with that… The post Voters Ask […]
    order-order
  • Take APCO’s party conference quiz & win a magnum of champagne! September 29, 2016
    The post Take APCO’s party conference quiz & win a magnum of champagne! appeared first on Guido Fawkes.
    WikiGuido
  • Germany Realises They’re Going to Be EU’s ATM September 29, 2016
    Liam Fox told the Spectator that Germany risks becoming the world’s biggest cash machine after Brexit because it may end up paying for a failing European Union that is in danger of imploding: “If I were a German politician I would be worried that, without Britain, Germany has the potential to become the greatest ATM in […]
    order-order
  • Jewish Groups and Corbynistas Condemn Jackie Walker September 29, 2016
    Labour’s standing in the Jewish community is at a new low after the party refused to comment on what action it would take against Jackie Walker. The chair of the Jewish Labour Movement Jeremy Newmark says: “If Royall, Chakrabarti and Jeremy’s speech yesterday have made any difference to anything we would have expected to see clear, […]
    WikiGuido
  • Bankers Bonus for Kevin Maguire September 29, 2016
    Kevin Maguire is a banker-basher extraordinaire – scroll through his tweets and he’s never leaving those “nasty bankers” alone, his Mirror column forever bangs on about the Tories being “banker’s friends” who are “out of touch with the public”. Well this morning our Kev’ and the Mail’s Andrew Pierce are entertaining clients at a BNP Paribas “Capitalise […]
    WikiGuido
  • What is a FOBT? September 29, 2016
    That was the question raised last week in comments relating to our latest Guido post – “Count Snowdon and the bloodsuckers are not libertarians”. When googling FOBT a few years ago, the top link was to Faecal Occult Blood Test, but google FOBT today, and the top link is to Fixed Odds Betting Terminals. However, […]
    WikiGuido
  • Labour Anti-Semitism Cover-Up September 28, 2016
    Labour will keep their response to the Jackie Walker anti-Semitism row private following new procedures adopted after the Chakrabarti inquiry. The party is under pressure to expel Walker over her comments on the Holocaust, yet Labour say they will not update the public on any action taken against her, a new policy recommended by Baroness Chakrabarti. A Labour spokesman says: “We don’t […]
    WikiGuido

RSS Bella Caledonia.

  • Scotland Continental September 30, 2016
    Columba, herring, Burns and Ossian helped put Scotland in Europe a long time ago, argues Neal Ascherson. In those stunned days after the Brexit vote was declared, John Swinney spoke to the Scottish Parliament. The Scots had voted to ‘Remain’, but the English UK majority had voted to ‘Leave’. Swinney had to explain why the […]
    Bella Caledonia Editor
  • How Long Has this Been Going On? September 30, 2016
    Every Friday we bring you our track of the week. This week we give you How Long has this Been Going On? from Fear of a Jazz Planet. H/T to The Bonnie Prince… In other news Nightmares on Wax have released their back catalog of mix tapes for free. Head over to Nightmare On Wax’s website to […]
    Bella Caledonia Editor
  • This is what democracy looks like September 30, 2016
    Sarah Glynn – member of Scottish Solidarity with Kurdistan was part of a Scottish delegation to the Democratic Union Party Congress in Brussels, discussing the democratic federalist system they are establishing in the autonomous predominantly Kurdish part of Northern Syria. She reports for Bella here. The Kurdish fighters of Rojava in northern Syria have become familiar […]
    Bella Caledonia Editor
  • The Defence of Trident September 29, 2016
    Trident isn’t a matter of left or right any more, or the ethics of pacifism or unilateralism, it’s become a constitutional issue. It matters that all of Britain’s ‘independent’ nuclear weapons are in Scotland. It matters that they are not in England. Rafael Behr today carefully analysed the splits and schisms in Corbyn’s Labour Party, […]
    Bella Caledonia Editor
  • Clinton Trumps the Donald September 27, 2016
    Likes(30)Dislikes(6)
    Bella Caledonia Editor
  • Jeremy Corbyn is Not the Issue September 26, 2016
    This week starts with the end of a twenty year entryist takeover of the Labour Party. The Blairite missionaries efforts have crumbled like a PFI school building. It is a failed ideology that has been rejected by its host. It’s time now for its advocates to leave and find another body to inhabit. It’s the […]
    Bella Caledonia Editor
  • 1983 September 25, 2016
    Like a lot of people, I’ve just been watching Jeremy Corbyn, overwhelmingly confirmed as leader of the Labour Party, say nothing I really disagreed with and doing pretty well (with comparatively soft questions) on the Andrew Marr show. The last time I voted Labour was in 1983, which was roughly the last time either Jeremy […]
    Bella Caledonia Editor
  • Perspective (get some) September 25, 2016
    We’re delighted to be partnering with Phantom Power films new venture, ‘Perspective’. He writes: ‘Our taster show is a magazine format with all kinds of different views on Scottish politics from film to comedy and profile. We hope you like it.’ Please enjoy share & support… Likes(27)Dislikes(5)
    Bella Caledonia Editor
  • Europe in Scotland #EU2 September 23, 2016
    In the third of our series inviting European citizens living in Scotland to reflect on the Brexit crisis, Svenja Meyerricks  contributes. #EU2 How has the Brexit vote altered your view of Britain? For me, the Brexit vote has been a disappointment in direct democracy. Reading some statistics about Leave voters made it abundantly clear that for […]
    Bella Caledonia Editor
  • The Gypsy Traiveller “problem” September 23, 2016
    Alistair Heather scrieves anent an ayebydand problem in landward airts o the kintrae, atween settled societie an the ‘gaun aboot fowk’ we cry Traivellers an Gypsies. Ane o Scotland’s ain indigenous ethnic minorities is bein squeezed oot o existence afore wir een, just as wir leaders are preachin aboot keepin open the doors tae aa […]
    Bella Caledonia Editor

RSS Wings Over Scotland.

  • The green and pleasant land September 30, 2016
    The Daily Telegraph just released a video called “100 Reasons Why Brexit Was A Good Thing”. It listed them to a soundtrack of “Jerusalem”, the same song that closed the Labour Party conference earlier this week with its stirring ode to just one of the four nations of the United Kingdom. We’ve saved a few of the highlights below, […]
    Rev. Stuart Campbell
  • Just your imagination September 28, 2016
    From a ridiculous piece by Hadley Freeman in today’s Guardian: Actually, we’re pretty sure it isn’t and we can. While we were compiling Kezia’s Greatest Hits, though, we also stumbled across this, which is our very favourite. It’s from almost exactly a year ago: How things change, eh readers?
    Rev. Stuart Campbell
  • Expressway to Lietown September 27, 2016
    Low-wattage Labour list MSP Neil Findlay (rejected by the electorate of Almond Valley by a thumping 8,393 votes in May) puffed himself up to maximum socialism this week and attacked the SNP’s rather more popular Paisley MP Mhairi Black over a Scottish Daily Express story about travel expenses. It might have been an idea if he’d read the […]
    Rev. Stuart Campbell
  • The voice of unity September 25, 2016
    You can see the full unedited Kezia Dugdale interview with Gordon Brewer on today’s Sunday Politics Scotland at this link, so you can verify that the shortened edit below isn’t misrepresenting anything. But if you don’t have time or attention span for the full 20 minutes, this’ll give you the gist without all the desperate […]
    Rev. Stuart Campbell
  • 20 Minutes In Hell September 25, 2016
    This is the longest piece of continuous TV exposure Kezia Dugdale will get between now and next year’s crucial council elections. Judge for yourself whether she seized the opportunity, readers. A Sunday Times/Panelbase poll released today put Scottish Labour’s support at 16%, with the SNP on 50% and the Tories on 21%. 
    Rev. Stuart Campbell
  • An absence of challenge September 25, 2016
    Kezia Dugdale isn’t even trying to make our life difficult. “I don’t think Jeremy can unite our party and lead us into government. He cannot appeal to a broad enough section of voters to win an election.” (22 August 2016) “I believe that Jeremy can unite the Labour Party [and] win a general election.” (24 September 2016) […]
    Rev. Stuart Campbell
  • Kez’s Nightmare September 24, 2016
    Chris Cairns
  • The squandered bounty September 22, 2016
    It’s long been a bone of contention for Scots – and not just nationalists – that the UK government, by common agreement, wasted the vast wealth windfall of the North Sea on funding Margaret Thatcher’s 1980s programme of deliberate de-industrialisation, mass unemployment, huge tax cuts for the wealthy and bribes to the working class in […]
    Rev. Stuart Campbell
  • The soggy deckchairs September 21, 2016
    With the greatest of reluctance, and only in the absence of anything even remotely more interesting, then, let’s have a few words on Scottish Labour’s latest solemn and sincere declaration of its full, total, complete and utter autonomy. Because while the media is reporting the development that UK Labour has decided to extend a few […]
    Rev. Stuart Campbell
  • Moving on September 19, 2016
    Exactly two years ago today (how time flies), we wrote this: It doesn’t seem overly immodest to say that we pretty much nailed it. But if that was then and this is now, what of tomorrow? A referendum in which Yes fell just 5.4% short of the winning post was never going to settle the […]
    Rev. Stuart Campbell

WP SlimStat