'May your choices reflect your hopes, not your fears' Nelson Mandela...
 

 

 

 
indy 2
 

The case for Scottish independence looks stronger post-Brexit

The decision to leave the EU changes terms of debate north of the border, writes Nicholas Macpherson

The EU referendum last month has raised existential issues of nationality across the British Isles. Applications for Irish passports are at a record level, with even Ian Paisley Jr, the Democratic Unionist MP, tweeting: “My advice is if you are entitled to [a] second passport then take one.” Meanwhile, the pressure for another referendum on Scottish independence is mounting.
With the UK leaving the EU, there is a golden opportunity for proponents of Scottish independence to reappraise their economic prospectus. Clearly, membership of the EU will lie at the heart of it. That will enable Scotland to have access to the biggest market in the world without the uncertainties that are likely to face the rest of the UK for many years to come. It would also provide a historic opportunity for Edinburgh to develop further as a financial centre, as London-based institutions hedge their bets on the location of staff and activities. If Royal Bank of Scotland, the state-backed bank, relocates its headquarters as part of that process, that would strengthen the long-term sustainability of the Scottish financial sector. How quickly an independent Scotland could join the EU is of course highly uncertain. Spain is unlikely to agree to automatic membership because of concerns about secessionist pressures in Catalonia. All the same, the EU has a huge interest in fast-tracking membership for a country whose citizens have been members of the bloc for 43 years and have voted to remain by 62 per cent to 38 per cent. Then there is the question of currency. In the run-up to the 2014 independence referendum, the Scottish National party government missed a trick by advocating a unilateral monetary union between an independent Scotland and the rest of the UK. The Treasury had had enough problems with fixed currency regimes in the 20th century without wanting to enter into one in the 21st. The history of monetary unions teaches us that they require more political integration rather than less — as the eurozone has discovered to its cost. In any case, an independent Scotland would have no interest in seeking to tie its currency to a country that wishes to put more distance between itself and the EU. It is surely time, therefore, for the Scottish government to commit to creating a Scottish pound supported by its own central bank. That would not preclude the monetary authorities of an independent Scotland from shadowing sterling, just as the Danish central bank shadows the euro. In the longer term, there could be a case for tying the Scottish pound to the euro. And a long-term commitment to joining the single currency would almost certainly be a requirement of EU membership. But that does not mean Scotland would have to adopt the euro — at least not straight away. Sweden is theoretically obliged to join the single currency. But more than 20 years on from joining the EU, the prospects of its giving up the krona seem vanishingly remote. One of the Treasury’s worries in 2014 about the putative monetary union between an independent Scotland and the rest of the UK was the impact of the oil price cycle. With its own currency, Scotland would be much better placed to respond to an oil shock on the scale of the one that has taken place in the past two years. Interest rates and the Scottish pound could take the strain smoothing any adjustment in the real economy. The fall in the oil price from $100 a barrel to under $40 earlier this year is a reminder of the importance of sound public finances. There is no reason why small countries cannot be very successful economically. But generally those that are — Norway and Singapore come to mind — put great effort into establishing fiscal credibility. That generally means running fiscal surpluses in the good times, the better to insure against shocks in the bad times. The Treasury was concerned in 2014 that the Scottish government’s prospectus relied on over-optimistic oil price projections. But First Minister Nicola Sturgeon’s administration has since worked to bolster its fiscal credibility. John Swinney, Scottish finance secretary until earlier this year, was cautious about using the borrowing powers available under the existing fiscal arrangements. More importantly, he has taken steps to set up Scotland’s own independent fiscal council. There is now a much better opportunity for informed debate about public finances, taking into account changing North Sea oil production levels and wider demographic trends. The Scottish government can strengthen its credibility by setting out long-term plans for public services, public investment and social security, in particular pensions. It also has a chance to set out a tax policy for the longer term. An independent Scotland committed to the EU would have an extraordinary opportunity to attract inward investment as well as highly skilled migrants. But, since it will be competing with Ireland, it needs a tax system that is equally competitive. That points to low corporate taxes and keeping marginal rates of income tax down. It may also point to a smaller, more efficient state. The aftermath of the EU referendum contains many lessons. Perhaps the most important is that without a plan for what happens next you risk months, if not years, of uncertainty and drift. The Scottish government is in a unique position to take a more far-sighted approach. If it can develop a clear and coherent economic strategy ahead of any future referendum, it not only stands a better chance of winning it will also increase the probability that an independent Scotland inside the EU can hit the ground running. The writer was permanent secretary to the Treasury and is now visiting professor at King’s College London FT.com FT  

RSS Guido Fawkes.

  • Will Self: Big Mac Bigot December 9, 2016
    McDonald’s plans to set up a holding company in the UK to pay tax on its global income outside the US. UK tax competitiveness reducing the burden for everyone. But not according to Will Self, who interrupted Nigel Farage on Question Time last night to derisively belittle 85,000 Golden Arches employees in Britain and more than […]
    Ross Kempsell
  • Murdoch’s Sky Takeover December 9, 2016
    The usual bed-wetters will freak out at the news that Rupert Murdoch is offering £18.5 billion for the 60.9% of Sky that 21st Century Fox does not already control. Sky shares jumped 32% on the news. Before Murdoch was rudely interrupted by the Leveson Inquiry he was poised to take control of Sky. Expect the BBC-Guardian […]
    order-order
  • BuzzFeed Outraged Over Telegraph’s Brexit Listicle December 9, 2016
    BuzzFeed have jumped on the outrage bus and attacked the Telegraph for naming the 89 MPs who voted against Article 50. Under the headline “The Telegraph Listed 89 Anti-Brexit MPs And People Are Not Impressed”, BuzzFeed says it is irresponsible to shame MPs in this way, suggesting it could inspire reprisals. Just like BuzzFeed did with its story “These Are […]
    Ross Kempsell
  • Labour Friends of Israel Condemn Corbyn December 9, 2016
    Responding to Jeremy Corbyn’s decision to go to notorious Israel hater Hatem Bazian’s book launch, Jennifer Gerber, Director of Labour Friends of Israel, told Guido Fawkes: We find it strange that Jeremy Corbyn would think it’s appropriate to attend an event organised by a group who say the party he leads is “indebted to Jewish […]
    Ross Kempsell
  • Friday Caption Contest (Europe 2016 Edition) December 9, 2016
    Entries in the comments please… The post Friday Caption Contest (Europe 2016 Edition) appeared first on Guido Fawkes.
    WikiGuido
  • Baroness Scotland Refuses to Answer Questions at Anti-Corruption Lecture December 9, 2016
    Baroness Scotland refused to answer questions about her conduct as she delivered Transparency International’s annual anti-corruption lecture last night. The organisers had said Scotland would address her expenses scandal, telling guests it was the “ideal opportunity for her to respond directly to those claims, as well as allowing members of the public and press to […]
    WikiGuido
  • Tories Lead By 17 Points December 9, 2016
    Guido is getting a little worried that Labour is bottoming too soon for a proper general election wipe-out. Tories up three points with YouGov, Labour down two, 17 points behind… The post Tories Lead By 17 Points appeared first on Guido Fawkes.
    WikiGuido
  • Corbyn Attends Khomeinist Event With Press TV and Israel Hating Extremists December 9, 2016
    Jeremy Corbyn attended an event hosted by a Khomeinist group on Wednesday night with Press TV and an infamous Israel hater. Guido can reveal Corbyn was at an Islamic Human Rights Commission event launching a book on Palestine by Hatem Bazian. It was chaired by Amina Taylor, who works for the Iranian regime’s television channel Press TV. The Islamic Human Rights […]
    WikiGuido
  • Labour Collapse in Sleaford December 9, 2016
    The Tories hold Sleaford, Labour fall from second in 2015 to fourth: Caroline Johnson, Conservative – 17,570, 54% (-2.7%) Victoria Ayling, UKIP – 4,426, 13.5% (-2.2%) Ross Pepper, LibDem – 3,606, 11.0% (+5.3%) Jim Clarke, Labour – 3,363 10.2% (-7%) Labour are briefing that this was a “difficult” by-election because of Brexit. Reality check for Remainers after Richmond… The post Labour […]
    WikiGuido
  • Who Is On Question Time Tonight December 8, 2016
    Auntie does spoil us… The post Who Is On Question Time Tonight appeared first on Guido Fawkes.
    WikiGuido
  • Expensive Lunch With Farage December 8, 2016
    Never let it be said that Guido doesn’t keep his word. His bet against Trump had to be settled. Lunch was no PFL – only a two bottler of a reasonable premier grand cru – Guido had to catch a flight and Nigel is doing Question Time tonight. In the circumstances Nige’ picked up the tab… […]
    WikiGuido
  • Corbyn’s Chum Jokes About Tory MPs Being Stabbed to Death December 8, 2016
    Bobby Gillespie is better known as the front man of nineties rockers Primal Scream. The band are big fans of Jeremy Corbyn, Gillespie says Jezza is “a good man” and the Labour leader even thanked him for his support with a tweet during his leadership campaign. Unfortunately Gillespie got a bit excited at a gig last […]
    WikiGuido
  • Bawdy Brexit Judges’ Supreme Court Smut December 8, 2016
    Lord Mance: “Withdrawal is the last thing on your mind when getting married” another justice: “Speak for yourself” pic.twitter.com/zMxfHu2URb — Esther Webber (@estwebber) December 8, 2016 A rude moment over at the Supreme Court as Lord Mance cannot resist a “withdrawal” pun. Filth. The post Bawdy Brexit Judges’ Supreme Court Smut appeared first on Guido […]
    WikiGuido
  • Disgraced Far-Left Lawyer Phil Shiner Admits Acting Without Integrity December 8, 2016
    The shamed far-left lawyer Phil Shiner is before the Solicitors Disciplinary Tribunal for his role in the vexatious claims against British soldiers who served in Iraq. An old CND comrade of Jeremy Corbyn, Shiner’s firm Public Interest Lawyers has already been closed down in disgrace and now Shiner faces 24 charges of his own. He has today admitted […]
    Ross Kempsell
  • Theresa and Philip May’s Christmas Cards December 8, 2016
    No photo of herself a la Dave, instead Theresa May has gone with a safe but sweet choice of three cards drawn by children in her constituency. First is Isabelle Milnes, aged 5: Then 11 year old Sophie Brazil: And Jade Windsor, also aged 11: Not a goose in sight… The post Theresa and Philip May’s Christmas […]
    WikiGuido
  • Vaz and Bercow Get the Party Started December 8, 2016
    Surreal moment in the Commons as Vaz congratulates Bercow on his and Sally’s anniversary, before asking if had a “party” last night. Remember, the Speaker and Vaz are close… The post Vaz and Bercow Get the Party Started appeared first on Guido Fawkes.
    WikiGuido
  • Blue on Blue: May Attacks Boris For Telling Truth About Saudis December 8, 2016
    Theresa May’s spokesman has issued a public slap down of Boris Johnson after he was caught on tape by the Guardian criticising Saudi Arabia. It’s a shame that the Guardian and the BBC think calling out a warmongering human rights abusing dictatorship is a “gaffe“. Now Downing Street has shot him down for telling the truth: “Those are the Foreign Secretary’s […]
    WikiGuido
  • MPs with Leave Constituencies Who Voted Against Article 50 December 8, 2016
    These are the names of the brave MPs with Leave constituencies who voted against triggering Article 50: Labour Graham Allen (Nottingham North) Nottingham voted Leave (50.8%) Chris Evans (Islwyn) Caerphilly voted Leave (57.6%) Paul Farrelly (Newcastle-Under-Lyme) Newcastle-Under-Lyme voted Leave (63%) Barry Sheerman (Huddersfield)  Kirklees voted Leave (55%) Angela Smith (Penistone and Stocksbridge) Sheffield voted Leave (51%) […]
    Ross Kempsell
  • Owen Jones’ Trotskyist Journey December 8, 2016
    In August Owen Jones blasted Tom Watson for saying Momentum is ridden with Trots: “The political significance of British Trotskyism is minimal… in the grand scheme of things, they are just irrelevant… There are too few Trotskyist activists to have any decisive impact on a party as big as Labour now is.” Then in September Owen attacked Channel 4 for […]
    WikiGuido
  • Named: The 89 MPs Who Voted Against Article 50 December 8, 2016
    One Tory, Ken Clarke, and 23 Labour MPs voted against triggering Article 50, as well as the LibDems and Scots Nats. Gavin Williamson, David Davis and Number 10 have played a blinder – a timetable for notification has been successfully agreed and those opposing have been flushed out. Below is the list of who voted […]
    WikiGuido

RSS Bella Caledonia.

  • Print Your Own Labels December 9, 2016
    Every six months or so I meet my friend’s son for a catch up. He’s twenty-one and has left home in the highlands for uni in Edinburgh. The last time we met he took his new girlfriend and the three of us went for coffee and a wander at the meadows. I asked his girlfriend […]
    Bella Caledonia Editor
  • Supporting Bella December 9, 2016
    Bella is ten years old next year and we’re organising some pretty special events to celebrate (details in January). Over that time have been building an ever-expanding community of writers, critics, journalists and thinkers with a commitment to challenging power and pushing for a Scottish democracy. But we need your help. We can only do […]
    Bella Caledonia Editor
  • Bein Yersels December 9, 2016
    “Tae be yersels an tae make that worth bein, nae harder job tae mortals has been gien.” – Hugh MacDiarmid Author, language activist, playwright, documentary maker and Bella editorial board member Billy Kay has been recognised for his contribution to Scots at Na Trads -2016 Scotland’s Traditional Music Awards 2016, from Dundee. You can watch […]
    Bella Caledonia Editor
  • Supreme Brexit December 8, 2016
    The derision that followed Kezia Dugdales IPPR speech yesterday was amplified by its coming on the same day as the Supreme Court ruling on Article 50. Most people will just be bored to tears by the Supreme Court proceedings and its turgid, dire, over-complicated nonsensical legalese. But it’s important. As Iain Macwhirter puts it succinctly: […]
    Bella Caledonia Editor
  • Change the Rules December 7, 2016
    On Wednesday Dec 21 we’re having a Review of the Year 2016, a year that many of you will be glad to see the back of. But just to be clear this isn’t a Review like others, of backslapping or maudlin remorse, it’s a review with the idea of response. Buy your tickets here. This […]
    Bella Caledonia Editor
  • BBC Question Time Cosy Friends Update December 7, 2016
    Earlier this week we broke the story of the BBC’s Fake Audiences on Question Time, and received a response from them yesterday – which seemed to simultaneously hide behind and hang out to dry their outsourced production company Mentorn Media – see ‘Fake Audiences Update’. We were pleased to see CommonSpace and The Canary develop the story, […]
    Bella Caledonia Editor
  • Brownhog Day December 7, 2016
      Today Kezia Dugdale tries (again) to carve out a niche in the world for her herself and her dying tribe. Yet more powers? Again? In her speech at the IPPR think tank, Miss Dugdale said: “The time has come for the rest of the UK to follow where Scotland led in the 1980s and 1990s […]
    Bella Caledonia Editor
  • Demanding Democracy December 7, 2016
    Christopher Silver’s ‘Demanding Democracy – The Case for a Scottish Media’ challenges the reader to ponder questions about Scotland’s broadcasting that far exceed the merely political or partisan. It is at first, an authoritative foray into the societal, cultural and economic origins of Scotland’s media both official and unofficial – print and otherwise. In all […]
    Bella Caledonia Editor
  • Fake Audiences Update December 6, 2016
    We recently raised questions about the role of the ‘Audience Producer’ for BBC Question Time and her role in manipulating and manufacturing audiences (‘BBC Question Time – Fake Audiences?’). We suggested that Alison Fuller Pedley (see ‘My Highlander’ – right) was using her personal political beliefs to influence her professional life, and in doing so […]
    Bella Caledonia Editor
  • Borrowed Time December 6, 2016
    ‘You can’t draw a line in the water… and yet the difference on either side is so clear. But it must shift with wind and weather and tide. A definable border, but unstable. I guess most borders are like that’. Jenni Daiches, in ‘Borrowed Time’, muses over the borders between youth and age, family and […]
    Bella Caledonia Editor

RSS Wings Over Scotland.

  • Red, white and blue December 10, 2016
    Order “Welcome To Cairnstoon”, Chris’ compilation of Wings cartoons and more, here.
    Chris Cairns
  • At the top of the dial December 9, 2016
    We’ll be honest, there are some bits of this that make us wince, and unfortunately most of them come in the first two minutes where they’ll do the most damage in terms of getting a persuadeable voter to watch the rest of it. But it’s an important piece of work, containing stuff even we didn’t […]
    Rev. Stuart Campbell
  • Return of the vortex December 8, 2016
    Particularly alert readers may recall a phenomenon we haven’t covered much recently, whereby aspects of politics magically transform as they cross the border between Scotland and the rest of the UK. But this week we’ve had a sighting in a new area. Sounds pretty bad for poor old Wales. The results weren’t so great for Scotland […]
    Rev. Stuart Campbell
  • Just following orders December 8, 2016
    Reiner Luyken is a 65-year-old German journalist who’s spent more than half of his life in the Highlands, and seems to have a knack for upsetting the neighbours. We’re sure it was just an unfortunate one-off misunderstanding. Oh. Perhaps not. Still, one thing that can be said is that when an instruction from a superior officer comes calling, […]
    Rev. Stuart Campbell
  • This time they really mean it December 7, 2016
    Alert readers may have noticed with barely-concealed disinterest that Scottish Labour have announced their intention to have another really hard think about devolution. With Labour not looking like being in power at either Holyrood or Westminster for at least a decade, and their opinions therefore being about as relevant as our ideas as to who […]
    Rev. Stuart Campbell
  • The Gambit December 5, 2016
    Unionists got very excited last week about a YouGov poll for the Times which showed that not only had the post-Brexit bump in support for independence been undone, but that it was now (fractionally) below the level recorded in the indyref for the first time since the September 2014 vote. (It was a slightly curious poll, […]
    Rev. Stuart Campbell
  • There’s no other way December 3, 2016
    Order “Welcome To Cairnstoon”, Chris’ compilation of Wings cartoons and more, here.
    Chris Cairns
  • Kezia Dugdale Fact Check, Part 677 December 1, 2016
    Here’s Kezia Dugdale at FMQs today. Just for fun, let’s do the sums again, shall we? As the FM pointed out, when Labour were last in power 85% of patients were treated within 18 weeks. The figures since the SNP took power are 96% within 12 weeks. But since Kezia Dugdale is apparently unable to […]
    Rev. Stuart Campbell
  • The passing of sentence November 30, 2016
    The Prime Minister of the UK, whose party has one MP in Scotland, officially tells the Commons that she doesn’t believe people on benefits should be able to survive. Happy St Andrews’ Day, readers.
    Rev. Stuart Campbell
  • The patron saint of North Britain November 30, 2016
    St Andrew is of course the patron saint of ALL of Scotland. He doesn’t belong to the SNP, or to nationalists, but to everyone in the country. So it hardly even seems worth pointing this out, really. Obviously there’s famously no political dispute over the monarchy. Nobody in Scotland minded this in the slightest either. […]
    Rev. Stuart Campbell

WP SlimStat