'May your choices reflect your hopes, not your fears' Nelson Mandela...
 

 

 

 
indy 2
 

The case for Scottish independence looks stronger post-Brexit

The decision to leave the EU changes terms of debate north of the border, writes Nicholas Macpherson

The EU referendum last month has raised existential issues of nationality across the British Isles. Applications for Irish passports are at a record level, with even Ian Paisley Jr, the Democratic Unionist MP, tweeting: “My advice is if you are entitled to [a] second passport then take one.” Meanwhile, the pressure for another referendum on Scottish independence is mounting.
With the UK leaving the EU, there is a golden opportunity for proponents of Scottish independence to reappraise their economic prospectus. Clearly, membership of the EU will lie at the heart of it. That will enable Scotland to have access to the biggest market in the world without the uncertainties that are likely to face the rest of the UK for many years to come. It would also provide a historic opportunity for Edinburgh to develop further as a financial centre, as London-based institutions hedge their bets on the location of staff and activities. If Royal Bank of Scotland, the state-backed bank, relocates its headquarters as part of that process, that would strengthen the long-term sustainability of the Scottish financial sector. How quickly an independent Scotland could join the EU is of course highly uncertain. Spain is unlikely to agree to automatic membership because of concerns about secessionist pressures in Catalonia. All the same, the EU has a huge interest in fast-tracking membership for a country whose citizens have been members of the bloc for 43 years and have voted to remain by 62 per cent to 38 per cent. Then there is the question of currency. In the run-up to the 2014 independence referendum, the Scottish National party government missed a trick by advocating a unilateral monetary union between an independent Scotland and the rest of the UK. The Treasury had had enough problems with fixed currency regimes in the 20th century without wanting to enter into one in the 21st. The history of monetary unions teaches us that they require more political integration rather than less — as the eurozone has discovered to its cost. In any case, an independent Scotland would have no interest in seeking to tie its currency to a country that wishes to put more distance between itself and the EU. It is surely time, therefore, for the Scottish government to commit to creating a Scottish pound supported by its own central bank. That would not preclude the monetary authorities of an independent Scotland from shadowing sterling, just as the Danish central bank shadows the euro. In the longer term, there could be a case for tying the Scottish pound to the euro. And a long-term commitment to joining the single currency would almost certainly be a requirement of EU membership. But that does not mean Scotland would have to adopt the euro — at least not straight away. Sweden is theoretically obliged to join the single currency. But more than 20 years on from joining the EU, the prospects of its giving up the krona seem vanishingly remote. One of the Treasury’s worries in 2014 about the putative monetary union between an independent Scotland and the rest of the UK was the impact of the oil price cycle. With its own currency, Scotland would be much better placed to respond to an oil shock on the scale of the one that has taken place in the past two years. Interest rates and the Scottish pound could take the strain smoothing any adjustment in the real economy. The fall in the oil price from $100 a barrel to under $40 earlier this year is a reminder of the importance of sound public finances. There is no reason why small countries cannot be very successful economically. But generally those that are — Norway and Singapore come to mind — put great effort into establishing fiscal credibility. That generally means running fiscal surpluses in the good times, the better to insure against shocks in the bad times. The Treasury was concerned in 2014 that the Scottish government’s prospectus relied on over-optimistic oil price projections. But First Minister Nicola Sturgeon’s administration has since worked to bolster its fiscal credibility. John Swinney, Scottish finance secretary until earlier this year, was cautious about using the borrowing powers available under the existing fiscal arrangements. More importantly, he has taken steps to set up Scotland’s own independent fiscal council. There is now a much better opportunity for informed debate about public finances, taking into account changing North Sea oil production levels and wider demographic trends. The Scottish government can strengthen its credibility by setting out long-term plans for public services, public investment and social security, in particular pensions. It also has a chance to set out a tax policy for the longer term. An independent Scotland committed to the EU would have an extraordinary opportunity to attract inward investment as well as highly skilled migrants. But, since it will be competing with Ireland, it needs a tax system that is equally competitive. That points to low corporate taxes and keeping marginal rates of income tax down. It may also point to a smaller, more efficient state. The aftermath of the EU referendum contains many lessons. Perhaps the most important is that without a plan for what happens next you risk months, if not years, of uncertainty and drift. The Scottish government is in a unique position to take a more far-sighted approach. If it can develop a clear and coherent economic strategy ahead of any future referendum, it not only stands a better chance of winning it will also increase the probability that an independent Scotland inside the EU can hit the ground running. The writer was permanent secretary to the Treasury and is now visiting professor at King’s College London FT.com FT  

RSS Guido Fawkes.

  • Saturday Seven Up July 30, 2016
    This recess week 219,236 visitors visited 622,330 times viewing 987,393 pages. The top stories in order of popularity were: Sarah Champion Unresigns From Labour Frontbench Kinnock ‘Hid Daughter’s £29,000-a-Year Private School’ During Selection McDonnell Looks Down the Camera Juncker Appoints Hardline Britain Basher as EU Brexit Negotiator Empty Seats at Smith Campaign Rally Lily Cole […]
    WikiGuido
  • Owen Smith Would Make Voters Less Likely to Vote Labour July 29, 2016
    When you’re polling worse than Jeremy Corbyn with the public… Via Britain Elects The post Owen Smith Would Make Voters Less Likely to Vote Labour appeared first on Guido Fawkes.
    WikiGuido
  • Corbyn Aide: Some in Leader’s Office Oppose Creation of Israel July 29, 2016
    Harry Fletcher, who has been a key aide in Jeremy Corbyn’s office for the last year, has blasted the leader’s team for their failings on anti-Semitism. Fletcher tells the Jewish Chronicle that Corbyn has a “reluctance” to speak with the Jewish community, suggests there could be a “deliberate refusal to engage with Jewish issues”, and says Jez has a “deep-seated problem” with […]
    WikiGuido
  • Watchdog Slams IMF’s Complacency, Lack of Transparency and EU Groupthink July 29, 2016
    A damning report by IMF watchdog the Independent Evaluation Office has slammed a “culture of complacency” in Christine Lagarde’s organisation. Focusing on the IMF’s response to the Eurozone crisis, the report claims that the Fund was riven with “issues of accountability and transparency”, claiming Lagarde and senior management established “small, ad hoc staff task forces” to plan […]
    guidobard
  • Friday Caption Contest (Don’t Pussy Out of Your Bet Edition) July 29, 2016
    Dan Hodges with the Downing Street cat. Entries in the comments please… The post Friday Caption Contest (Don’t Pussy Out of Your Bet Edition) appeared first on Guido Fawkes.
    WikiGuido
  • Smith’s London-Centric Sauvignon Socialists July 29, 2016
    As of Friday lunchtime 63 constituencies have declared their Labour leadership nominations: 51 for Corbyn and 12 for Owen Smith. Eight of Smith’s 12 nominations come from London CLPs and he has just one backer north of the M25 – he really is the metropolitan elite candidate. One of the CLPs which did vote for Oily was the leafy […]
    WikiGuido
  • Corbyn’s Venezuelan Comrades Pass Forced Labour Law July 29, 2016
    Time for an update from the socialist paradise of Venezuela. This week their tyrannical president Nicolas Maduro, ideological brother of Jeremy Corbyn, Diane Abbott, Owen Jones, Seumas Milne et al, was condemned by Amnesty International for passing a “forced labour” law. Maduro signed the decree giving the state power to compel citizens to go and work in the fields. […]
    WikiGuido
  • 27 Countries Seeking UK Trade Deals July 29, 2016
    The above map shows all the countries in which government officials or prominent business figures have declared a desire to secure a post-Brexit trade deal with Britain. Out of the 10 largest economies in the world, just two (France and Italy) have not yet made moves for a deal. Every continent on earth is represented, with 27 […]
    guidobard
  • Hinkley’s Welcome Pause July 29, 2016
    Gaia has been sceptical of the case for Hinkley Point C on the grounds of cost, the history of over-runs and the manifest problems with these type of EPR reactors. The guaranteed price of the energy and the subsidy required seem a high price to pay – even considering the strategic importance of have diversity […]
    order-order
  • SpAd List Taking Shape July 28, 2016
    Theresa May’s Downing Street team is slowly taking shape – her former SpAd and Vote Leave alumnus Stephen Parkinson is to be given a role. All of David Cameron’s SpAds were told to clear their desks and just two have been brought back into the fold, Rachel Wolf and super-SpAd Sheridan Westlake. New Secretaries of […]
    WikiGuido
  • Corbyn Stays on the Ballot July 28, 2016
    The attempt by Labour moderates to stop Corbyn through the courts fails. LOLabour! The post Corbyn Stays on the Ballot appeared first on Guido Fawkes.
    WikiGuido
  • Martin Brunt’s Partridge Moment July 28, 2016
    “If I was a terrorist, I could have killed them all.” The post Martin Brunt’s Partridge Moment appeared first on Guido Fawkes.
    guidobard
  • Macho, Laddish Culture of BBC Wales Boyos July 28, 2016
    Reconstruction. A veteran BBC Wales correspondent gets in touch with curious tale that took place at the Beeb’s Cardiff studios a few years back. The office was renowned for its macho, laddish culture, sexual shenanigans and boyo banter. The women in the newsroom were often on the receiving end of the work-hard-play-hard mentality of the blokes. One day, a young […]
    guidobard
  • Anti-Faragists Plot to Keep Woolfe Off Ballot July 28, 2016
    Anti-Faragist forces on UKIP’s National Executive Committee are working to keep Steven Woolfe off the ballot, according to sources in the room. The NEC is dominated by supporters of Neil Hamilton and Douglas Carswell who want to stop the Farage candidate and install Lisa Duffy as leader. Woolfe is backed by Nigel and a string of his […]
    WikiGuido
  • Toby Perkins: “I Love to Show My Body” July 28, 2016
    Looks like Labour MP Toby Perkins has been clicking on dodgy links… UPDATE: @GuidoFawkes My account got hacked, it's nothing to do with what I was looking at, thank you. — Toby Perkins MP (@tobyperkinsmp) July 28, 2016 The post Toby Perkins: “I Love to Show My Body” appeared first on Guido Fawkes.
    WikiGuido
  • Obama’s Convention Speech for Hillary July 28, 2016
    The full 49 minutes of Obama’s oratory… The post Obama’s Convention Speech for Hillary appeared first on Guido Fawkes.
    order-order
  • Trump Asks Russia to Hack Hillary’s Emails July 27, 2016
    Trump Expressly Asks Russia To Hack Clinton’s Emails https://t.co/PPKqIPXFVm pic.twitter.com/RVxDllsOD6 — BuzzFeed News (@BuzzFeedNews) July 27, 2016 The post Trump Asks Russia to Hack Hillary’s Emails appeared first on Guido Fawkes.
    WikiGuido
  • New Transport PPS “Strongly Opposed” to HS2 July 27, 2016
    HS2 may have hit another rail bump. The new Transport PPS, Victoria Prentis, is “strongly opposed” to building the high-speed rail link. Prentis, whose picturesque rural constituency of Banbury would see HS2 run through its eastern edge, says on her website: “While I recognise the importance of investment in our transport network, I am strongly opposed […]
    guidobard
  • Owen Smith: I’m Sorry July 27, 2016
    Owen Smith has apologised via his spokesman for saying he wanted to “smash” Theresa May “on her heels”: “It was off script and, on reflection, it was an inappropriate choice of phrase and he apologises for using it.” He hasn’t commented himself other than to stand by his comments… He’s had a full spanking from Jess […]
    WikiGuido
  • Smith Campaign Chief Insists He’s “Not a Sexist” July 27, 2016
    Not what Owen Smith’s team wanted to be talking about today… The post Smith Campaign Chief Insists He’s “Not a Sexist” appeared first on Guido Fawkes.
    WikiGuido

RSS Bella Caledonia.

  • Hillary and the Balloons July 29, 2016
    I’m looking at the pictures of Hillary among the balloons…as a theatre type…and thinking to myself, a bit uncomfortably… “She may have intelligence and experience and ruthlessness going for her, but she is a TERRIBLE actor. I mean, just…God help us…” (A bit like Gordon Brown…when compared to Tony Blair…only being America. the contrast with […]
    Bella Caledonia Editor
  • Perspective July 29, 2016
    This looks like an excellent addition to the emeregnt new media landscape from the talented Phantom Power Films… “PERSPECTIVE is a new regular documentary series that covers politics, art and culture in Scotland in the 21st century. From Phantom Power Films, the team which brought you Altered State, comes a powerful new documentary format shot […]
    Bella Caledonia Editor
  • Would you like anything in your Independence? Aye, mair independence. July 28, 2016
    Even before we become independent has the SNP sold out Scotland, to The City of London? I sincerely hope not, and not just because I voted SNP, but a little red light of unease has been blinking in my mind since February 2015 when I inspired an MSP with my ideas and helped her to […]
    Bella Caledonia Editor
  • Clinton Coronation July 27, 2016
    Likes(21)Dislikes(12)
    Bella Caledonia Editor
  • Feeling the heat yet? July 25, 2016
    Last Wednesday was great. I stepped out into the blistering Leith sunshine, dark shades at dip, and walked about twenty yards before running into a huddle of associates sat outside a Leith Walk boozer, supping lager, soaking up the rays, as you do. Naturally, I joined them. As you do. By late afternoon the temperature […]
    Bella Caledonia Editor
  • United Togetherness July 25, 2016
    A ‘Reverse Greenland‘ sounds like something from a Nordic Kama Sutra. It is instead the unlikely proposition that Scotland stay in the EU and in the UK. But as the Brexit consequences unfold before us, the connection between the unmuzzled right’s Europhobia and their economic project is also becoming more obvious. It’s not just Sir […]
    Bella Caledonia Editor
  • Better Together Campaign July 24, 2016
    This presentation by Rob Shorthouse is remarkable for a number of reasons, not least astonishing levels of assumption-making and self-deception (which we’ll explore fully in a subsequent blog). But thanks to eagle-eyed Alistair Davidson for spotting the admission about how ‘Better Together had “banks of people” at HQ organised in “twitter squads” (about 13m in)’. […]
    Bella Caledonia Editor
  • Wedding Invite meets Suicide Pact July 24, 2016
    The letter from Jackson Carlaw to Kezia Dugdale calling for a new Tory/Labour “alliance” opposing #indyref2 via the marvelous and unlikely source of Michael Blackley, the Political Editor of the Scottish Mail on Sunday. As Martyn Bennet would have it: “This is the LORD’S doing; It is marvelous in our eyes.” Likes(19)Dislikes(6)
    Bella Caledonia Editor
  • The Corbynite Manoeuvre July 24, 2016
    It’s fashionable to deride anything and everything about the Labour Party. I’ve been doing it for a decade, charting their decline and collapse. There was a time when ‘Red Tory’ was a lazy slur, then it became a simple descriptor. But it’s to our benefit to have a progressive England to our south, as we […]
    Bella Caledonia Editor
  • Scottish Govt – Act Now to Stop “Catastrophic Impact” of Cuts on Disabled Community July 23, 2016
    Disability campaigners and their allies are urging the Scottish Government to act NOW to stop the horrendous benefits cuts being inflicted on disabled people. Following a demonstration at the Scottish Parliament activists from Black Triangle and Disability History Scotland presented a petition with this demand to be considered by the First Minister. “We are hopeful […]
    Bella Caledonia Editor

RSS Wings Over Scotland.

  • When time stood still again July 30, 2016
    Yes supporters are currently holding what seems to be a very well-attended march from Glasgow’s Botanical Gardens to a rally in George Square, with thousands more people seemingly turning up than even the organisers’ highest pre-event estimates. We could verify that with footage from the Labour-controlled City Council’s webcam at the square, if it hadn’t […]
    Rev. Stuart Campbell
  • Slow train coming July 30, 2016
    Chris Cairns
  • An empty quiver July 29, 2016
    This week I published, through Common Weal, a discussion paper on the potential currency options for an independent Scotland in light of the material changes in circumstances caused by the Brexit vote. This paper examines some of the options open to an independent Scotland and concludes that, on balance, the best option for Scotland would be a Scottish currency, […]
    Dr Craig Dalzell
  • A great day for child abusers July 28, 2016
    Well done to everyone concerned. Paedophiles and the Daily Mail will be partying hard tonight. Although as it later transpired, only for a while. The Supreme Court ruled that while the Named Persons legislation needed a small tweak on data-protection grounds which will most likely delay it for a few months, condemning more children to […]
    Rev. Stuart Campbell
  • The darling of the comrades July 26, 2016
    A new YouGov poll of Scottish voters was released today. It had no voting-intention figures, and concerned itself mostly with people’s assessment of the main Scottish and UK party leaders. The Labour-voters column was interesting to say the least. That’s rather a lot of love for a Tory PM from people who voted Labour at […]
    Rev. Stuart Campbell
  • Fluid times July 26, 2016
    A brief note on the current futility of political commentary. Remember that? Well, let’s see how it really works. Here’s a couple of days before the EU referendum vote: And here’s a month after the vote: And here’s a little reminder of something from page 3 of The Wee Blue Book: It’s almost like we […]
    Rev. Stuart Campbell
  • The King Of Facts July 24, 2016
    Posted without comment.
    Rev. Stuart Campbell
  • Congratulations to President Trump July 24, 2016
    On his certain victory. (A reminder of John’s most recent banker bet is below.) (And of his Greatest Hits.)
    Rev. Stuart Campbell
  • Two men dealt amongst the chill July 23, 2016
    Chris Cairns
  • The quantum of bias July 20, 2016
    “Bias” is a word we hate. Other than in the article you’re about to read, you’ll almost never find it used on this site, for a string of reasons. It’s one of those words that – regardless of context or literal justification – simply makes people switch off instantly and dismiss your arguments. (See also: “Zionist”, “Quisling”, […]
    Rev. Stuart Campbell

WP SlimStat